By Ray O’Hanlon
Political leaders from North, South and across the Irish Sea are meeting in Belfast today in an effort to sort out the political impasse caused by the North Executive’s failure to pass a welfare bill.
The talks are also aimed at fully implementing the Stormont House Agreement reached last Christmas.
The survival of the current government in Belfast is seen as being on the line.
The talks involve the Irish and British governments, and all five political parties represented in the Assembly.
Ireland’s Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade, Charlie Flanagan, and Minister of State Seán Sherlock, are representing the Irish government in what is being formally dubbed “a Review and Monitoring meeting of the Stormont House Agreement.”
“The failure last week of the Welfare Bill to secure approval in the Northern Ireland Assembly, and the consequent budgetary implications, have a direct and major impact on the prospects for implementing the totality of the Stormont House Agreement,” said a statement from Flanagan’s department.
“Accordingly, following consultation with the British Government, it was decided that a Review and Monitoring meeting of the Stormont House Agreement would take place this week. All five of the Northern Ireland Executive parties will attend.”
Meanwhile, the Irish Times was reporting that two former Irish-American congressman have called on Northern Ireland’s parties and the British and Irish governments to seek a compromise on the budget cuts that have led to political stalemate.
James Walsh and Bruce Morrison said in a joint letter to North leaders that they believe a compromise can be reached to accept the current cuts envisioned by the Stormont Agreement coupled with a deal by the British government for a three-year moratorium on future welfare cuts.
“Northern Ireland should be in a much better place economically and socially in three years if the Stormont Agreement is broadly implemented,” the two said.
The North would benefit from “the resulting economic and political stability can produce increased inward and local investment in job-creating development.”
Walsh, a Republican, and Morrison, a Democrat, stated that this stability was “absolutely essential for the promotion of investment in Northern Ireland by American companies.”
Their proposal would provide the basis “for a renewed effort by each of you to resolve the current impasse impeding the further implementation of the Stormont Agreement.”
The letter was sent to North Secretary of State Theresa Villiers, Minister Flanagan and Northern Ireland First Minister Peter Robinson and Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness.
Added the Times report: “Mr. Walsh and Mr. Morrison noted in their letter that the burdens on Northern Ireland from the recession and decades of the Troubles “make the prospect of further welfare cuts a matter of great concern.”
They pointed to the high rates of post-traumatic stress disorder in Northern Ireland and suicide, referring to a statistic that suicide is 63 per cent higher in Northern Ireland than the rate in Britain.
“We are concerned that a ‘one size fits all approach’ to welfare reform for the United Kingdom negates this striking reality of Northern Ireland’s recent past,” they wrote.
Even as leaders were gathering in Belfast, investment and jobs in Belfast, and the rest of Northern Ireland, were poised to take center stage at the sixth annual New York/New Belfast conference to be held at the Fordham Lincoln Center campus in Manhattan Wednesday, Thursday and Friday of this week.
By Ray O’Hanlon
The Irish American Republicans lobby group has come out against the recent rescinding of Florida’s MacBride Principles law by the Sunshine State’s GOP governor, Rick Scott.
In a strongly worded statement, the IAR said it was urging Governor Scott to “inform himself” regarding the current situation in Northern Ireland.
Said the IAR statement: “While we acknowledge the progress made since the Good Friday Accords, assisted by a period of incredible economic growth throughout Ireland, we also know that anti-Catholic sentiment is still very palpable in Northern Ireland.
“One needn’t live there to be aware of it; any visitor can see the signs, literal signs, of the tension that remains. Stout concrete wall be between neighborhoods have been built to keep the peace. In spite of our lingering substantial racial issues this is not a step that America has ever found necessary. It is an indication of how far Northern Ireland has to go.”
The statement saw no merit in Florida turning its back on a MacBride law that, up until a few days ago, had been on the state’s books since 1988.
It said: “To step back from the McBride Principles at this juncture is tantamount to endorsing the bigotry that has and does plague Irish society. Any pressure to do so can only originate from those who would profit from continued discrimination against Northern Ireland’s Catholic minority. No American politician who plans to remain in office should want himself identified with that effort.”
The statement concluded: “We urge Governor Scott to inform himself of the situation that exists in Northern Ireland, and reject this very bad idea.”
The rescinding was put into effect by Gov. Scott’s signature attached to a line item in Florida’s state budget.
Meanwhile, WGCU, National Public Radio station serving south West Florida, reported on the rescinding thus: “Florida Gov. Rick Scott signed nearly fifty bills into law this week. One of them lifted decades-old restrictions on doing business with Northern Ireland.
“The move has raised the ire of Irish Catholics.”
The report continued: The MacBride Principles were created in the mid-’80s to protect Catholics from economic discrimination in Northern Ireland. Among other things, they require employers to have a percentage of Catholics on staff.
“Florida — along with 17 other states and the federal government — adopted the principles. That means the Florida Pension Fund can invest in Northern Irish companies only if they prove they’re abiding by the principles.
But the new law does away with the investment restriction.”
By Ray O’Hanlon
The U.S. Congress and President Obama should join Amnesty International in demanding action in the aftermath of a BBC television documentary casting light on alleged state-linked murders during the Troubles in Northern Ireland.
“The United States must not be silent about this BBC exposure of forty years of British government state terrorism in Ireland, one of the longest terrorist campaigns in history,” said Fr. Sean McManus, president of the Washington, D.C-based Irish National Caucus.
Amnesty has called for an investigation after the BBC documentary program “Panorama” reported claims that agents inside loyalist and republican terror groups were able to kill and target victims with impunity during the Troubles.
Reported the Guardian newspaper after the documentary, entitled “Britain’s Secret Terror Deals,” was broadcast Thursday night: “Lady Nuala O’Loan, the former police ombudsman in the region, branded informers who were allowed to commit crimes including murder while in the pay of the British state as ‘serial killers.’”
The report added that Panorama had alleged that in many instances the security forces – RUC special branch, military intelligence and MI5 – helped cover up killings carried out by their agents.
Said O’Loan: “They were running informants and they were using them. Their argument was that by so doing they were saving lives, but hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of people died because those people were not brought to justice and weren’t stopped in their tracks. Many of them were killers and some of them were serial killers.”
Patrick Corrigan, Amnesty International’s program director for Northern Ireland, said: “The breadth and depth of collusion being alleged here is truly disturbing.
“Killing people targeted by the state, using intelligence provided by the state and shooting them with guns provided by the state – if all this is proven, we’re not talking about a security policy, we’re talking about a murder policy.
“There must now be a full, independent investigation into the scale of the policy where the police, army and MI5 worked with illegal paramilitary groups, resulting in the deaths of perhaps hundreds of people.”
The documentary, according to the Guardian, focused on links between the RUC, army and MI5 with the Ulster Defence Association and the Ulster Volunteer Force, but also explored allegations from the families of those killed by the IRA that, in some cases, those involved in murdering their loved ones were informers for the British state.
Meanwhile, the political crisis in the North prompted by the failure of the Welfare Bill to secure approval in the Northern Ireland Assembly has prompted the Irish and British governments to convene next week for what is being described as a “Review and Monitoring” meeting focused on the Stormont House Agreement.
Invitations have been extended by the governments to the leaders of the Northern Ireland Executive parties. The meeting will take place on Tuesday, June 2.
By Joe Biden
Last weekend more than 1.2 million Irish voters took a courageous stand for love and family when they overwhelmingly chose marriage equality.
They recognized the fundamental truth that every person is entitled to dignity and respect, and that there can be no justification for the denigration or persecution of anyone because of who they love or who they are.
I want to thank my good friends Taoiseach Enda Kenny, and Tanaiste Joan Burton, for their forceful leadership and eloquent advocacy on this critical issue.
I cannot improve upon the perfectly Irish statements they made following this historic vote, but I can echo the Taoiseach’s words when he described the Irish as “a generous, compassionate, bold and joyful people,” and that their choice will be “heard loudly across the living world as a sound of pioneering leadership.”
In 22 years, Ireland has gone from a nation where simply being LGBT was against the law. Now, it is a nation where the people resoundingly stand for equal rights.
And here in the United States, in just the past three years we’ve gone from six states recognizing marriage equality, to 37 states, comprising 224 million Americans. It’s about love. It’s about equality. It’s about dignity. It’s about our most cherished values. That’s what this is about – it’s all it’s ever been about.
There is still work to be done. There are still too many nations that deny people even the right to be safe from violence and severe discrimination, and too many states here in America that allow a person to be fired simply for being lesbian, gay, transgender or bisexual.
But the progress is undeniable. As advocates in Ireland, the United States and around the world have proven time and again, where there’s passion and commitment, there is opportunity.
I continue to believe that in every corner of the world, people want to do the right thing. You should never underestimate the epiphanies that follow when a culture makes a breakthrough of conscience.
But it takes leadership. It takes courageous individuals who are willing to step forward, to turn adversity into positive change, and to truly live the words of the great Irish poet William Butler Yeats: “Do not wait to strike till the iron is hot, but make it hot by striking.”
Actor Jack O’Connell, center, actor-playwright Erin Layton and actor-playwright Don Creedon were in the audience last night for this month’s Artists Without Walls Showcase. PHOTO: PETER MCDERMOTT
By Peter McDermott
Einstein played the violin.
So Polly Toynbee reminded us a recent piece in the Guardian, making the case for more arts in education rather than less.
And referring to an institution founded in London in 1660, she said: “Recent research found science Nobel laureates are 25 times more likely to sing, dance, act and paint than other Royal Society members, and 12 times more likely to write poetry and novels.”
The veteran columnist was on strong ground, then, in arguing that the “arts enhance other talents.”
Toynbee took to task a recent British Conservative education minister Michael Gove and his successor, Nicky Morgan, for their biases against the arts.
She also had something to say, in this regard, about a contest being held in the main opposition party.
“In the lineup of Labour leadership potentials, how to choose between these able, good-looking and experienced Oxbridge graduates?” (One of the four announced candidates, incidentally, is a daughter of the diaspora. Mary Creagh’s mother, originally from Northern Ireland, was a primary-school teacher and her father, from the Republic, a car-factory worker.)
“The list of qualities required [for the leadership job] is probably impossible to combine within one human frame,” Toynbee said. But the candidates would certainly be a lot more interesting, she felt, if they revealed a passion for something outside of political life, and what could be better than arts performance? She cited the example of the pol who took piano exams and another who played Mendelssohn, which helped make them “plain talkers in a world of ear-aching politics-speak.”
There were plenty of suggestions on display last night at the monthly Artists Without Walls Showcase at the Cell Theater in Manhattan. Wouldn’t you like to see your — or indeed any — public representative try to meld hip hop and Irish dance like the guys from Hammerstep? Or get up there with a guitar, as Cavan’s John Munnelly did, and amuse a crowd with a song about Julius Caesar? Or, as Noel Lawlor does sometimes, though not last night, recite a soliloquy or some other type of piece from Shakespeare?
In her piece, Toynbee made the more general case for performance. “No one forgets any school play they were in,” she said. “No discipline is tougher than acting in front of an audience, learning a part, speaking up to be heard. All those are skills vital to jobs in later life, as employers complain of young people mumbling and slouching in interviews. But fewer schools employ drama teachers.”
As for the Bard himself, Toynbee added: “The Royal Shakespeare Company’s work with schools, training teachers to teach Shakespeare performance, showed remarkable results: performing a play transformed attitudes to both Shakespeare and to school.”
William Shakespeare in the Chandos portrait at the National Portrait Gallery.
By Irish Echo Staff
The biggest-ever delegation of political leaders from Belfast will attend next week’s New York-New Belfast conference and this just as Irish America refocuses on the prospects for the Northern Ireland peace process.
Members of the Stormont Assembly from five different parties will attend the sixth annual conference at Fordham University Lincoln Center campus on Thursday evening June 4, and on Friday June 5.
They will be joined by their counterparts from New York City Hall, Albany and Capitol Hill who have been staunch supporters of both the peace process and transatlantic partnerships.
Over one hundred delegates are already registered for the conference which will be opened on Thursday evening by Fordham President Fr. Joseph McShane and New York-based Belfast actress Geraldine Hughes.
Among opening night highlights will be a presentation on “Game of Thrones” which is filmed in Northern Ireland and is generating a mini-tourist industry of its own. Opening night will also feature a preview of the $54 million new Irish Arts Center in New York.
On Friday, the focus switches to business with New York State Comptroller Tom DiNapoli — who last year committed $15 million to a Belfast equity fund for start-ups — taking the podium at the U.S.-Ireland Top Companies luncheon.
Backed by premier business partner KPMG, the conference will close with a finale reception at the Midtown residence of Irish Consul General Barbara Jones.
For more details on the conference, or to register, go to www.aisling-events.com.
Taoiseach Enda Kenny was able to brief Ban Ki-moon first hand on the result of the same sex marriage referendum. The United Nations Secretary General is in Ireland to receive the Tipperary Peace Award. Photocall
By Irish Echo Staff
Ireland made history.
That’s the view of Taoiseach Enda Kenny in the aftermath of last Friday’s referendum vote clearing the way for same sex marriage in the Republic.
Following the vote, the Oireachtas will now draw up legislation that will lead to a new amendment being inserted in the Constitution that recognizes and protects the institution of marriage without regard to sexual orientation.
Prior to the referendum, same sex civil unions were recognized in the Republic but not full marriage which, as an institution, is formally protected by the Constitution.
Once the Dáil and Seanad complete their part in the process, the enabling legislation will be signed by President Michael D. Higgins.
Mr. Kenny said he welcomed the result of the vote and he thanked all those who voted in the referendum.
“In the privacy of the ballot box they made a public statement,” he said
The ‘Yes’ vote had “disclosed who we are – a generous, compassionate, bold and joyful people. Yes to inclusion. Yes to generosity. Yes to love, and
Yes to equal marriage.”
Continued Mr. Kenny: “The people have answered the call of families and friends, of neighbors and new acquaintances.
“Of Jack O’Rourke and Edel Tierney, Finian Curran and Allie Kershaw and Jerry, Leo, Pat and so many others. It was their stories and their voices that inspired the hearts and minds of the Irish people.
“Our people have truly answered Ireland’s Call.
“The referendum was about inclusiveness and equality, about love and commitment being enshrined in the constitution. For a significant proportion who voted against the amendment it was because of genuinely held views which are to be respected.
“The decision makes every citizen equal and will strengthen the institution of marriage for all existing and future marriages. All people now have an equal future to look forward to.
“So – the people went to the polls. It passed. The answer is yes. Yes to their future. Yes to their love. Yes to their equal marriage.
That yes is heard loudly across the living world as a sound of pioneering leadership of our people and hopefully across the generations of gay men and women born as we say, before their time. The people have spoken. They have said yes. Ireland – thank you.”
Tommy Sands will present on Saturday night a theatricalized music event based on his 2005 memoir.
By Daniel Neely
Tommy Sands is a living legend. He’s a widely respected singer and songwriter from County Down who grew up in the music. He has performed the world over, from New York to Moscow and everywhere in between and is a man who advocates passionately for the things he believes in. Not only is his music widely admired, but he’s become known the world over for his activism and humanitarian work. Throughout his entire life, he’s made it a point to sing out and make a difference, a way of being that has not only attracted the admiration of his musical peers, but also that of folks like Seamus Heaney, Frank McCourt, and Mary McAleese, to name but a few.
Indeed, there is great power in Sands’s music. His songs are cherished and have been performed by the likes of Joan Baez, Mick Moloney, Robbie O’Connell, Dolores Keane, Sean Keane, Frank Patterson, Dick Gaughan and Kathy Matthea, all of whom have helped make his work part of the living tradition. Take, for example, a pair of songs from his 1985 album “Singing of the Times,” “There Were Roses” and “Daughters and Sons.” They’re not just a classic songs, they’re are profound political statements and deep meditations on peace and humanitarianism. The same can be said of “Music of Healing,” a song Sands wrote with the legendary Pete Seeger for his 1995 “Hearts A’Wonder” album. Not only does it address Sands’s humanitarian concerns most poignantly, it helped inspire an innovative peace education program that has global relevancy.
These songs are symbols of a life that’s been fully lived and one that continues to strive to realize its fullest potential. This idea is reflected in Sands’s 2005 memoir “The Songman – A Journey in Irish Music.” In it, he explores his life growing up in Northern Ireland not only in music, but during the civil rights movement. In ruminating on the sentiments and sensibilities those experiences engendered, he spins a richly detailed story about people and music (among the many yarns are episodes recounting the times he had with the likes of The Bothy Band and Pete Seeger, for example) but also about struggle, forgiveness, and justice. It’s a remarkable story, presented in a way that has universal appeal.
Although New York City audiences have seen Sands a couple of times in the last few years as a participant in other artists’ shows, it has been quite some time since he was featured on his own. This will change on this Saturday, May 30, when Sands appears at the Irish Arts Center’s Donaghy Theatre. There, Sands will present a theatricalized music event based on his memoir. It will feature brilliant songs, intimate storytelling, striking imagery and, of course, humor. It’s a rare opportunity to see one of the great legends in the music perform in so intimate a venue.
This will be an exciting, soul stirring show. Sands is a charismatic performer and his enduring, iconic work speaks about Irish history and identity in a unique and engaging way. I cannot recommend this show more highly. For more information on the evening, visit irishartscenter.org. For more information about Sands and his work, visit www.tommysands.com.
Daniel Neely is the Irish Echo’s traditional music columnist.
By Ray O’Hanlon
It is three months this week since a letter was sent by Ireland’s Department of Foreign Affairs to the U.S. Embassy in Dublin on the matter of visa waivers for the undocumented Irish.
Receipt of the letter was acknowledged by the embassy, and there was also an indication that a reply would be forthcoming.
In the intervening months there have been discussions on the waiver issue between senior officials and political figures in both the Irish and U.S. government.
Irish foreign affairs minister, Charlie Flanagan, and U.S. Ambassador to Ireland. Kevin O’Malley, are understood to have discussed waivers on at least two occasions in the last month or so.
And the plight of the undocumented Irish has come up for discussion in the Dáil in recent days.
In a Dáil questions and answers session, Fianna Fáil TD, Brendan Smith, asked Minister Flanagan “if he will provide an update on his efforts on behalf of undocumented Irish emigrants in the United States of America; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
A reply on behalf of the minister stated: “Achieving relief for undocumented Irish migrants in the U.S. is a priority for the Government in our contacts with the United States.
“Through our Embassy in Washington and our Consulates throughout the U.S., we continue to work closely with high level Government contacts and with many other individuals and groups across Irish America and beyond. All of this work is aimed at achieving relief for undocumented Irish migrants in the United States and improved channels for legal migration between Ireland and America.
“During his visit to the U.S. in March and in a series of high level contacts with the U.S. Administration, with Congress and at State level, the Taoiseach raised the issue of immigration reform and the plight of the undocumented Irish, stressing that almost every family in Ireland is related to or knows somebody who is caught up in this deeply distressing situation.
“During his meeting with President Obama on 17 March the Taoiseach commended him on his executive action announced late last year. This action is currently the subject of legal proceedings in the U.S. federal courts. The Taoiseach emphasized the need to allow the undocumented to come out of the shadows and be free to travel home for family events.
“He also highlighted the issue of those amongst the Irish undocumented who might be eligible for visas, but who would be required to return to Ireland for their issuance and hence would require waivers for their prior period of undocumented residence.
“The Taoiseach also pointed to the need for a legal pathway to allow for future Irish immigration to the U.S. for those who wish to make a contribution there, expressing the hope that a political way forward could be found on this issue which would encourage progress on a comprehensive legislative package by Congress.
President Obama spoke of his executive actions on immigration reform and acknowledged the contribution of Irish immigrants to America’s development. He considered that one of the great strengths of the United States had always been its willingness to welcome new immigrants to its shores.
“I also raised immigration reform issues, including the possibility of immigration reform legislation and the question of visa waivers, when I met with Vice President Biden in Boston on 30 March. I have also had the opportunity to discuss these matters on a number of occasions recently with U.S. Ambassador O’Malley.
“In addition, the Taoiseach discussed immigration issues with Congressman Paul Ryan during his recent visit to Dublin on 30 March. The Government as a whole, including my Department in Dublin and our Embassy in Washington, will continue to actively follow up on all of the issues raised in recent contacts with the US Administration, with Congress and with the U.S. Embassy in Ireland.”
The waiver issue focuses on permitting undocumented immigrants to travel back to Ireland without triggering the three or ten year bars that would prevent them from returning to the U.S.
As the Irish Echo previously reported, it is possible to obtain visa waivers permitting travel back to Ireland, and, critically, a return to the United States.
But Ireland trails a number of countries in terms of securing visa waivers according to figures compiled by the U.S. State Department.
A list of the top twelve waiver-winning countries for the past three fiscal years shows Ireland in eighth place in each of those years.
In fiscal 2014, Irish applicants were granted 118 waivers, though there were also 280 refusals.
Ireland trails Mexico which is in first place with 8398 waivers in fiscal ’14, though Mexican applicants were also refused 35244 times.
Interestingly, the second place in the waivers-gained table, at 2211, is occupied by “Great Britain and N. Ireland,” which would presumably mean that some Irish passport holders from the North secured waivers to travel.
The figures were obtained by the Irish Lobby for Immigration Reform which has been campaigning for an end to the exclusion bars.
Also ahead of Ireland in the table, and beginning with third place, were Australia, Bermuda, Colombia, Norway and New Zealand. Immediately trailing Ireland in the list were Germany, the Dominican Republic, South Korea and Japan.
Waivers that remove the three and ten year bars are a matter for U.S. embassies and consulates, hence the importance of a response to the DFA letter from the U.S. Embassy in Dublin
In a “guidance” document for such diplomatic outposts, the State Department highlights the discretionary powers that embassies and consulates retain in the matter of waivers.
The document states in part: “ The Congress, in enacting INA 212(d)(3)(A), conferred upon the Secretary of State and consular officers the important discretionary function of recommending waivers for nonimmigrant visa (NIV) ineligibilities to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) for approval.
“You should not hesitate to exercise this authority when the alien is entitled to seek waiver relief and is otherwise qualified for a visa, and when the granting of a waiver is not contrary to U.S. interests.
“The proper use of this authority should serve to further our immigration policy supporting freedom of travel, exchange of ideas, and humanitarian considerations, while at the same time ensuring, through appropriate screening, that our national welfare and security are being safeguarded.”
In cases where waivers are granted it is often the case that the applicant might be a parent of a U.S. citizen child or children, even though the applicant, he or she, might be undocumented.
By Ray O’Hanlon
As expected, Governor Rick Scott of Florida has signed a state budget bill that includes, in its multitudinous line items, a bill that rescinds the state’s MacBride Principles law.
The budget bill, which had to be passed in totality or not at all, was signed by Scott Thursday even as Ancient Order of Hibernians members in the state were inundating the governor’s office with calls.
The Florida MacBride law had been on the books since 1988, a year of particularly strong MacBride activity across the U.S.
And in another development, it has emerged that Nebraska, with little fanfare or fuss, rescinded its MacBride law in 2011.
The rescinding was presented in January of that year to legislators on the state’s Retirement Systems Committee as a money saving measure.
The amount saved was, according to a transcript of the committee’s deliberations obtained by the Echo, $8,500.
With Florida and Nebraska subtracted, the principles are today law in just 16 states, though they are also enshrined, since 1998, in U.S. federal law.
The Florida rescinding measure was an item in the overall budget bill generated by “Bill Analysis and Fiscal Impact Statement” drawn up for the Florida Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on General Government.
The bill, SB 7024, was then introduced in the Senate back in early March by the Government Oversight and Accountability Committee. The impact statement cover page also refers to the State Board of Administration.
The language 7024 is dry and matter of fact; it give virtually no hint of a political hand behind it. The bill even lists the MacBride Principles.
Nevertheless, the rescinding of the Sunshine State’s MacBride code is prompting an immediate pushback from pro-MacBride groups such as the AOH and Irish National Caucus.
In a statement, Greg Seán Canning, AOH Florida State President, expressed “great disappointment” after receiving a call from the governor’s office “informing me that Governor Scott signed Senate Bill 7024 into law.”
Canning continued: “Despite the loss of our initiative to prevent this legislation from becoming law, there is some positive news. First, the Governor’s office stated that they were inundated with phone calls all day. They also stated that they never realized how organized the AOH was and the strength of our response.
“That being said, I would like to express my gratitude for the quick response from our Brothers, Sisters, and Friends both in and outside of Florida. We only learned about Bill 7024 a few days ago. This Bill was held up in committee throughout most of the legislative process. This kept it out of the public eye.
“When it was finally released, the Senate only had two days to consider it. Many knew nothing of its ramifications. They were informed that this legislation would help the economic situation in the North and that because of the progress being made within the 6 Counties, the Mac Bride Principles were no longer needed. By the time this Bill became public knowledge, it was too late.”
Canning followed up with a call to action stating in part: “First, while we would rather engage in a struggle that we would have a better chance of winning, we cannot always turn away from those that offer little to no chance of success.
“There are those situations (this being one of them) when we as an organization must take a stand based on ethics. If we must always base our actions on victories only, then we have failed as an organization with principals. There will be those times when we will have to engage an issue even if there is no chance of success. I believe that this situation needed a strong response from us.
“Going forward, we must all keep a close watch on future economic bills that might serve to alter the current economic situation in Northern Ireland. This bill may well pave the way for stronger legislation in Florida or similar legislation in other States.
“Make no mistake, the MacBride Principles are under attack. We must seriously think of how to inform legislators from other States on the ramifications of removing the protection of the MacBride Principles in Northern Ireland. Doing so can and will reopen the doors of economic discrimination against the Irish Catholic Nationalist population within the 6 Counties.”
Fr. Sean McManus, president of the Irish National Caucus and the most high profile MacBride campaigner in the U.S. since the 1980s, didn’t mince his words describing the Florida rescinding as “anti-Catholic, anti-Irish.
Said the Washington, D.C.-based McManus in a statement released before Governor Scott signed the budget bill: “If Florida’s governor were to sign a Senate Bill to repeal the MacBride Principles, it will be seen as anti-Catholic and anti-Irish — whatever the governor’s intentions.
“Why would the Florida Senate attempt to do this? Who manipulated them in such a way? The MacBride Principles are universally regarded as being the most important and effective campaign ever against anti-Catholic discrimination in Northern Ireland.
“The Governor would be profoundly ill-advised to be associated with such an awful act. The MacBride Principles were passed to ensure that Florida dollars would not subsidize anti-Catholic discrimination in Northern Ireland. Those who are opposed to these principles will logically and naturally be seen to be anti-Catholic and anti-Irish. That’s politics 101.”